Metabolife Lawsuit
Public Citizen consumer group has been pushing for an ephedra ban
for years. On September 5, 2001, the consumer group petitioned the
FDA in support of an ephedra ban due to the unreasonable risk
of illness or injury the supplement poses. The petition to
ban ephedra included two requested actions; a ban on the sale and
production of ephedrine alkaloid dietary supplements, an immediate
FDA advisory to stop the use of ephedrine alkaloid dietary supplements
due to the established risks of injury.
Included in the Public Citizen petition for the ban of ephedra
containing products like Metabolife was note of Metabolife founder
and co-owner Michael Ellis criminal record. Ellis was convicted
in 1990 on a drug-related charge for the illegal manufacture and
sale of methamphetamine and pleaded guilty to a felony charge. Methamphetamine
can be produced from ephedra.
On November 19, 2002, Ellis surprised a lot of people by refusing
to have his deposition taken or to answer questions by claiming
his Fifth Amendment right. The opposing attorney found Ellis
reaction surprising because he failed to even defend Metabolife,
the ephedra-containing diet pill that the company has still continued
to maintain is safe. The federal jury penalized Metabolife by ruling
the company pay $4.1 million to four people that had suffered stroke
or heart attack after using Metabolife.
The FDA had been trying to obtain Metabolife side effects reports
from the company for years, dating as far back as 1997 but was unable
to gain the companys cooperation. The attempt to gain court
order to collect the records was denied in the past. Ellis wrote
a letter to the FDA dated April 17, 1998 stating ephedra was being
safely used and there were no reports of ephedra dangers. Despite
Ellis claims, the FDA continued collecting evidence to the
contrary, with reports of over 100 deaths among ephedra users, inclusive
of Metabolife.
In August 2002, the Justice Department announced a criminal investigation
was starting to determine if Metabolife was deceitful to the FDA
in the claims that Metabolife users had made no adverse event reports.
The day the criminal investigation was announced, Metabolife International
handed over 14,700 reports of Metabolife side effects to the FDA.
Although the FDA had anticipated a high number of ephedra adverse
reports, the agency did not expect it to be as high as it was.
There have now been 145 personal injury lawsuits filed against
Metabolife International for the nations largest selling ephedra
product. So far, 29 of the Metabolife personal injury suits have
been settled with a total of over $5 million. On November 19, 2002,
the first Metabolife case to make it to trial ended, resulting in
the ruling that Metabolife International must pay $4.1 million to
four Metabolife consumers that had suffered strokes or heart attacks
after taking the ephedra diet pills. The jury in found Metabolife
to be unreasonably dangerous. The decision made by the federal jury
was reached after expert witness testimony and the thousands of
Metabolife records of consumer complaints were reviewed.
Still facing more than 100 Metabolife personal injury cases in
both state and federal court, Metabolife continues to maintain their
ephedra product is safe. Metabolife has now sent over additional
records of 1,480 Metabolife customer complaints that were received
in a five-month time period in 2000 but the company claims was lost
due to a computer glitch. Included in these additional records were
three deaths, 20 heart attacks, and 24 strokes. Still, Metabolife
International does not find any Metabolife dangers to be attributed
to ephedra and maintain the safety and efficacy of Metabolife.
For more information on metabolife lawsuits, please contact
a Metabolife Lawyer.
Metabolife
Ordered to Pay
On November 19, 2002, the first Metabolife case to make it to trial
ended, resulting in the ruling that Metabolife International must
pay $4.1 million to four Metabolife consumers that had suffered
strokes or heart attacks after taking the ephedra diet pills. The
federal jury found the ephedra-containing product Metabolife to
be unreasonably dangerous. The decision made was reached after expert
witness testimony and the thousands of Metabolife records of consumer
complaints were reviewed.
Still facing more than 100 Metabolife personal injury cases in
both state and federal court, Metabolife continues to maintain their
ephedra product is safe. Metabolife International has already paid
around $5 million to settle 29 Metabolife cases. For more information
on ephedra, please contact us.
Top of Page
Metabolife
Under Criminal Investigation
Metabolife Internationals ephedra-containing diet pill was
widely popular, topping annual sales at $1 billion. In August 2002,
the Justice Department and the Internal Revenue Service announced
an investigation on Metabolife was to be carried through to determine
if Metabolife and Metabolife co-founder Michael Ellis lied to the
FDA about former claims that the company had not received any consumer
complaints of serious Metabolife dangers.
For years the FDA had been trying to obtain reports of ephedra
dangers from Metabolife, and ironically the same day the Justice
Department Investigation was announced Metabolife handed over 14,700
reports made by consumers that had experienced adverse effects from
Metabolife to the agency. Letters dating from 1998 issued to the
FDA from Ellis state Metabolife had not received any consumer reports
of Metabolife side effects. On November 19, 2002, Metabolife turned
over an additional 1,480 consumer complaints of Metabolife side
effects that the company claimed were previously lost in a computer
glitch.
For more information on metabolife lawsuits, please contact
a Metabolife Lawyer.
|